Lincoln’s plan for Reconstruction included the Ten-Percent Plan, which stated that a southern state could be readmitted into the Union once 10 percent of its voters swore an oath of allegiance, or loyalty in other words, to the Union. Then voters could elect representatives to draft new state constitutions and create new state government. All southerners would be given a full pardon except for high-ranking Confederate army officers and government officials. Lincoln promised southerners that he would protect their private property, but not their slaves. Most moderate Republicans in Congress supported the president’s plan for Reconstruction because they wanted to bring a quick end to the war.

Lincoln wanted to end the war quickly. He feared that a long-drawn-out war would lose public support and that the North and South would never be reunited if the fighting did not stop quickly. His fears were correct. For example, by late 1863, a large number of Democrats were asking for a truce and peaceful end to the war. Lincoln’s Ten-Percent Plan was very easy on the South, as an effort to get the South to surrender.

President Lincoln seemed to favor self-Reconstruction by the states with little help from Washington. To appeal to poorer whites, he offered to pardon all Confederates; to get former plantation owners, he promised to protect private property. Unlike Radical Republicans in Congress, Lincoln did not want to punish southerners or reorganize southern society. His actions showed that he wanted Reconstruction to be a short process in which secessionist states could create new constitutions as fast as possible so that the United States could exist as before. But his assassination in 1865 cut his plans for Reconstruction.  

Many leading Republicans in Congress feared that Lincoln’s plan for Reconstruction was not strong enough, they believed that it was needed and wanted the South to be punished for causing the war. These Radical Republicans hoped to control the Reconstruction process, change southern society, destroy the planter class, redistribute land, develop industry, and guarantee civil rights for former slaves. In the summer of 1864, the Radical Republicans passed the Wade-Davis Bill to counter Lincoln’s Ten-Percent Plan. The bill stated that a southern state could rejoin the Union only if 50 percent of its voters swore an ironclad oath of allegiance to the United States. The bill also created safeguards for black civil rights, but the drawback was that this bill did not give blacks the right to vote.

At the end of the Civil War, in the spring of 1865, Lincoln and Congress were on the brink of a political showdown with their opposing plans for Reconstruction. But on April 14, John Wilkes Booth, a popular stage actor from Maryland who was sympathetic to the South, shot Lincoln at Ford’s Theatre in Washington, D.C. When Lincoln died the following day, Vice President Andrew Johnson, a Democrat from Tennessee, became president.

Lincoln’s assassination gave Radical Republicans in Congress the clear path they needed to start their plan for Reconstruction. The new president, Andrew Johnson, had seemed supportive of punishing measures against the South in the past, because he disliked the rich southern planter and believed they had been a major cause of the Civil War. But Johnson surprised Radical Republicans by constantly blocking their efforts to pass punitive laws for the South. 

Johnson, a Democrat, favored stronger state and believed in the principle of laissez- faire , which stated that the federal government should stay out of the economic and social concerns of its people. Even after the Civil War, Johnson believed that states’ rights took priority over central authority, and he disapproved of legislation that affected the American economy. He rejected all Radical Republican attempts to dissolve the plantation system, reorganize the southern economy, and protect the civil rights of blacks. 

Although Johnson disliked the rich southern planter, his actions contradicted himself. For instance, he pardoned more people than any president before him, and most of those pardoned were wealthy southern landowners. Johnson also shared the southern racist point of view that former slaves should not receive the same rights as whites in the Union. Johnson opposed the Freedmen’s Bureau because he felt that targeting former slaves for special help would be bad for the South. He also believed the bureau was an example of the federal government taking political power reserved to the states, which went against his pro–states’ rights belief.

Like Lincoln, Johnson wanted to restore the Union in as little time as possible. While Congress was in recess, the president began fulfilling his plans, which became known as Johnson’s Plan or Presidential Reconstruction. He returned property to white southerners, issued hundreds of pardons to former Confederate officers and government officials, and weakened the Freedmen’s Bureau by ordering it to return all confiscated lands to white landowners. Johnson also appointed governors to supervise the drafting of new state constitutions and agreed to readmit each state provided it ratified the Thirteenth Amendment, which abolished slavery. Hoping that Reconstruction would be complete by the time Congress resumed a few months later, he declared Reconstruction over at the end of 1865.

Northerners felt Congress was not being harsh enough toward the South. Many northerners were troubled by the presidential pardons Johnson had handed out to Confederates, his decision to strip the Freedmen’s Bureau of its power, and the fact that blacks were basically slaves again on white plantations. Many in the North believed that a president sympathetic to southern racists and secessionists could not correctly reconstruct the South. As a result, Radical Republicans overwhelmingly beat their Democratic opponents in the elections of 1866, ending Presidential Reconstruction and starting the era of Radical Reconstruction.

After the elections of 1866, the Radical Republicans gained almost complete control over decision-making in Congress. They gained control of the House of Representatives and the Senate and thus gained enough power to override any potential vetoes by President Andrew Johnson. Congress began the job of Reconstruction by passing the First Reconstruction Act in March 1867. The bill reduced the confederate states to little more than conquered territory, dividing them into five military districts, each governed by a Union general. Congress declared martial law in the territories, sending troops to keep the peace and protect former slaves.

Congress also declared that southern states needed to rewrite their constitutions, ratify the Fourteenth Amendment, and give the right to vote to blacks in order to get back into the Union. They also placed Union troops in charge of voter registration. Congress overrode two presidential vetoes from Johnson to pass their plan. 

Radical Republicans hoped that by declaring martial law in the South they would be able to create a Republican political base in the seceded states to help their plans for Radical Reconstruction. Though most southern whites hated the regimes that Congress created, they proved successful in speeding up Reconstruction. Indeed, by 1870 all of the southern states had been readmitted to the Union. 

To conclude, reconstruction processes held by presidents differentiate from each other though the main content is the same. All of them have benefits and drawbacks, however it helped society to develop towards the Civil Rights. On top of that I can also add that latter reconstruction policies completed the previous ones and eventually it saved the Union.